Activating the Desire to Learn
by Bob Sullo
Introduction, Ch. 1, Ch. 6, Ch.11
I am thrilled to have chosen a great book. It will be in my personal Library.
Activating the Desire to Learn was written in 2007. Some of Mr. Sullo’s other books are Teach Them to be Happy, Inspiring Quality in Your School: From Theory to Practice and The Inspiring Teacher: New Beginnings for the 21st Century. Mr. Sullo has a simple and effective style that allows the abstract theories to be easily related to the practical. His case studies and “What you can do” points at the end of each chapter make it a very practical read.
This book is simply about motivation and inspiration. Through the systematic break down of motivations’ components and its relationship to human behavior, a clear strategy emerges that can improve the effectiveness of nearly anyone in leadership, from the teacher to the superintendent. I recognized the principles now in practice within some of the business world, and I can truly vouch for its efficacy.
The Introduction
Mr. Sullo begins by asking us to reflect on a task we have been “made” to do. We complete the task, but probably didn’t give our best effort. Then reflect on a task for one of our best efforts. There was extra satisfaction that occurred in our best effort, We FELT something. We remember it with more detail. We may even smile while we’re thinking about it. The difference in the performances was motivation. Where did the motivation come from? Mr. Sullo maintains there is a set of internal needs at our core. We have an intrinsic desire to fill these needs. Motivation is the manifestation of our desires. The book details how we perceive these needs, and as educators, how to use them. For more information on this root concept, it is an approach based on Internal Control Psychology.
Chapter 1
Mr. Sullo begins by subtly denigrating the traditional reward-response technique that is still the most prevalent behavior modification model in use today. He explains this reward-punishment model is based on a belief that human behavior is created by external stimulus. Not only does he counter this model for education, but he actually believes it is anti-educational. On the surface this seems a little out there, but he explains that the reward-punishment model conditions students to feel if there is no reward involved, it must not be worth learning. He quotes William Powers, a noted developer of perceptual control theory “People control their own experiences. The only way you can truly force them to behave as you wish is through the threat or actuality of overwhelmingly superior physical force—and even that is only a temporary solution..”
Can’t we relate to times our parents bribed us to do something? The bribe made us instantly know we wouldn’t do it by CHOICE! Choice Theory is a detailed theory of human behavior, and is integral to the understanding of internal control Psychology and therefore internal motivation.
The single most important concept of this book is that motivation is INTERNALLY generated. To quote Mr. Sullo “Internal control psychology is based upon the belief that people are internally, not externally, motivated. Powerful instructions that are built into our genetic structure drive our behavior. The outside world, including all rewards and punishment, only provides us with information. It does not make us do anything.”
Mr. Sullo postulates that at any given moment, our behavior represents our best attempt to satisfy these four basic psychological needs:
- Belonging or connecting
- Power or competence
- Freedom
- Fun
One important point to make is these are PSYCHOLOGICAL needs. Physical needs can and will supersede these as Maslow so deftly points out.
The chapter goes on to detail these four basic needs. But one important point from the chapter helps us to understand this internal control behavior in relation to our current mindset of external control behavior. Cause and effect is inherent as a means of analysis, but Mr. Sullo outlines that the external cause we see was first internalized as information and then interpreted through a filter of our perceived understanding of these psychological needs. This is an important concept because it can help us make sense out of behavior that otherwise makes no sense.
The idea is even though this internal filter could be skewed by unhealthy experiences or false beliefs; it is still what we use to reconcile our reality.
Chapter 6
This chapter is a case study of Nathan. Nathan is a 4th grader. He is asked a series of questions about school. Nathan has an effective teacher that understands internal motivation and is applying it to the classroom. He outlines the things he likes about the way his teacher manages the classroom and learning.
Besides offering a practical example of how internal motivation can improve the educational process, a discussion on “consequences”. This relates to internal motivation as it gives a student a framework to fulfill his psychological needs externally.
The emphasis the consequences can be good things depending on our choices, and not just bad. The re-enforcement that good choices have good consequence is just as important as the alternative.
Chapter 11
This started with a case study of “Dave”. He is a high school English teacher with about 10 years under his belt. He was conditioned by his supervisors that he was considered a good teacher if he didn’t have behavior problems in his classroom. The attitude was controlling the class was more important than his ability to teach. In short, he was conditioned to operate externally for control.
He attended a seminar that explored motivation and introduced him to internal control Psychology. He began using the principles and quickly began to see results. He took it a step farther and began teaching about some of the fictional figures in their literature assignment and began asking the students explore what the internal motivations were for these characters. This caused the students to open up and become much more engaged in the readings. It made the characters real to the students. It offered stark examples of how our perceptions are created and how we act on them regardless of if the perceptions were accurate.
Several more case studies of high school students are contained in this chapter. Each detailing one of the four core psychological needs. How they were manifested in the student, and how Dave used his new found knowledge of internal control psychology to remedy the situation.
Questions
Remember a task you have accomplished where completing the task WAS the reward.
What made it so? How can you instill that into a student?
What are ways to get a student “buy-in” to an assignment?
What are ways to instill the notion of personal responsibility into a student?
In Summary, this is a well written book. Its liberal use of case studies makes application of Mr. Sullo’s hypotheses straight forward. From this book and our previous readings I find his ideas completely realistic. It follows Maslow’s hierarchy of needs by offering a greater detail of how the mind handles the top three tiers. I find no conflict here.
In addition I find this book to became a bridge to help us understand and put in context the ideas and theories presented by Daniel Pink, and the Conceptual age.
“Reaching Both Sides of the Brain, and How We Do it” could have been the title of this book.
The 21st Century educator must ascend for new skills. This book is most assuredly one rung in the ladder. Bill_H
I have always been a big believer in intrinsic motivation but do struggle with a way to instill that in the students if they are inclined to be motivated by external awards.I believe positive reinforcement and praise when a student does well can lead a student to be proud of his/her accomplishmen.An extremely positive attitude of the teacher and a belief in his/her students can hopefully motivate the students to do well.
ReplyDeleteThat's true Mieke, but Sullo's point is the external award is just information. Only when that information is filtered through their internal belief system is motivation created. That's why some students do not respond the same as others. The award is the same, but their internal processing is not...
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting...Bill_H
You asked us to remember a time when the completion of a task WAS the reward. Quite frankly, I tend to view most tasks that way. Even if I am "required" to do a task that I don't want to do, I tend to try even harder to do the task well just to "show them" so to speak. This probably speaks to the internal motivator of control or power, I suppose. Referring back to the rewarding tasks, when I truly analyze what is going on when I find great satisfaction in a job well done, I have to admit that I get great pleasure from affirmations from others. I guess I'm having trouble determining whether my satisfaction comes more from doing the task well, or from the accolades of others. Even if I received no praise from others, I would still be pleased with the task results, but I still find it hard to separate the task from the affirmation.
ReplyDeleteI think I agree with Mieke regarding praise as a motivating tool for students. Deep down inside I believe we all want to do things well, AND want to be recognized for it. I do feel that praise must be used in moderation, not overdone, and it must be genuine. I also think it depends on the student. Some are comfortable with very public accolades, but others would be extremely embarrassed by public recognition. Finding ways to affirm those students in a more subtle manner still lets them know you noticed their effort without drawing attention to them directly.
Buy-in and responsibility I think go hand-in-hand. Allowing student choice helps in both of these areas. It's pretty cool to see 'ownership' of projects as they take shape. As students are given more responsibility for a task, they naturally achieve more buy-in and ownership of that project. Just some more thoughts....
You're right on Dean!
ReplyDeleteThe distinction has to do with the new found understanding of the mechanisms involved.
In some respects it is a nuance, but understanding its intrinsic root allows for a better analysis of behavior, especially at the fringes where our at-risk students dwell.
Thanks! Bill_H
Intrinsic motivation is slowly fading away. Students now a days, have been given everything they want in life without having to work for it. This is the type of attittude/behavior they bring to class. It is our job as teachers to instill intrinsic motivation and not as much external stimulus. The must realize that hard work pays off. Not always externally but within. Something to carry with you and make you a better person.
ReplyDeleteI thought about a task I accomplished where completing the task was the reward, and immediately I thought of a scenic design class I took in undergrad. The night before a project was due, almost the entire class would be in the basement of the performing arts building working on our models. There was a lot of swearing and laughing, pizza delivery, tears, music, and movies. As the night wore on, people would drift in and out, catching naps or teasing each other for finishing first. I can remember walking back to my dorm room as the sun came up, and I don't know if I've ever felt more proud or accomplished.
ReplyDeleteI think it's a matter of finding a way to make students have pride in their work. They should feel like their assignment actually matters, and that when it's done it won't collect dust in a closet until the day they graduate from college and their parents make them clean out their rooms.
Maybe a good way to do this is to include things like community service in the project. A class studying poverty, for example, could volunteer at a food pantry or center for the homeless, or work on a Habitat for Humanity home. In an English class they could publish a whole-class compliation book of stories, poems, essays, etc. and have it stocked in the classroom library or even in the school library. This way their work means something more than just a grade.
Ahhh, PRIDE!
ReplyDeleteThe ability to instill this into a student.
That's precisely the reward Sullo is talking about. Very good point!! Bill_H
In addition when I completed the task, just completing it was my main reward. I was glad to have finished it and hoping I would get a good grade on it. To instill the notion of personal responsibility into a student would be effort and determination. They must know that when they give their all and not give up it gives a sense of accomplishment. Something they can apply with future assignments or life chanllenges.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Bill, we must find a way for the students to take pride in their work. Its not giving half-hearted efforts, but to want to do something well for yourself. That is the key to instill inside the student. As far as a project, i would have to say the task was to get my first scouting report done at Wichita State. I took a lot of pride in it because it was a statement that I made to my boss, our players and the fans and let them know that I was very qualified for the job. We ended up winning by about 20+ because a couple of weaknesses I was able to expose. It took a lot of work, but it was something that I took pride in. I did a lot of those and other jobs/task that I didn't get a lot of credit like making sure travel arrangements were done, where I didn't get credit when I did something right, but was blamed when one thing went wrong. But I took pride in doing little tasks that most people took for granted.
ReplyDeleteIt is hard to get students to buy in about their education. I hope to try real world examples and the notion that they will be back in the same classroom if they dont take it serious.
ReplyDeleteI agree it’s hard to get their buy-in on education, but I think the idea is that their education is a by-product of finding ways on a daily basis to get buy-in. This buy-in thing is a continuous process with every lesson..
ReplyDeleteJust to be clear, the notion of having to repeat a grade is a threat, NOT an internal motivation…;-)
Bill_H
Right now I'm taking an american lit class from a professor who is a notoriously hard grader. One of our assignments was to write a 4-6 page paper over a piece of american literature. I put a lot of time and effort into this paper knowing that this prof had high expectations. So after many hours of writing and revising, I finally turned in my paper. Before I received my grade I was already proud of my work; we got our papers back the next day and I almost fell over when I got an A-. I think having high expectations for your students is a great way for them to be engaged in their work; they know they have to work hard to get a good grade and will be very satisfied when they do the work and get the good grade. I know I was. :)
ReplyDeleteFor me the task that acted as the award would have to be getting back into shape and lifting weights. This was very rewarding to me because I love to play sports and this enabled me to be back in the shape I was in during high school. Not only do I feel healthier but I have more energy as well which helps me through the day.
ReplyDeleteI think a way for getting students to buy into an assignment would have to be rewards for great work. Maybe this could even work as a class effort by giving a reward such as a fieldtrip or some other outside activity. I could set standards that the students need to fulfill and they can encourage and help each other achieve these goals by a type of buddy system. Also it brings into play a team like atmosphere where each student is there for one another.
As for personal responsibility for the student, I think that this can be achieved by emphasizing to the student that they shape their lives by the choices they make. If they want to achieve certain goals then the students need to realize that their responsible actions are necessary to attaining their goals. Students need to realize that every choice they make has a cause and effect nature that determines where they will end up. They need to realize that even though the decisions they make may seem unimportant in the present, they will be able to see that every decision made has an effect on future events.
This is Bob Sullo. Nice to read such thoughful commentary. Regardless of whether you agree with me, I am excited that you are discussing the importance of fostering internal motivation in students. Enjoy....
ReplyDelete